Medication Selection Tool for Alcohol and Opioid Dependence
Your Situation
Recommended Options
Select your situation above to see recommendations.
Naltrexone is a medication used to help people stop drinking alcohol or using opioids. It doesn’t cure addiction, but it blocks the euphoric effects of these substances, making them less rewarding. That’s the core idea: if you can’t feel the high, you’re less likely to keep using. But naltrexone isn’t the only option. People trying to recover from addiction often wonder: is there something better? Or at least something that works better for me?
How Naltrexone Works
Naltrexone hydrochloride is the salt form of naltrexone, the active ingredient. It’s available as a daily pill or a monthly injection (Vivitrol). Both versions work the same way: they bind tightly to opioid receptors in the brain, preventing alcohol and opioids from activating them. For alcohol, it reduces cravings and the pleasurable effects. For opioids, it stops heroin or prescription painkillers from working at all. If someone takes opioids while on naltrexone, they won’t feel anything - no rush, no relief. That’s a powerful deterrent.
It’s not a sedative. It doesn’t make you sleepy or high. You don’t get withdrawal symptoms if you stop taking it. That’s why many people prefer it over medications that cause dependence themselves. But it only works if you’re already off opioids. If you take naltrexone while still using opioids, you could go into sudden, severe withdrawal. That’s why doctors require a 7-10 day opioid-free period before starting.
Alternatives to Naltrexone
There are several other FDA-approved medications for alcohol and opioid use disorders. Each has different mechanisms, side effects, and use cases. Choosing the right one depends on your history, goals, and lifestyle.
Acamprosate (Campral)
Acamprosate is used only for alcohol dependence. It doesn’t block the high - instead, it helps stabilize brain chemistry after stopping drinking. Heavy drinking changes how your brain handles glutamate and GABA. When you quit, those systems go haywire, leading to anxiety, insomnia, and strong cravings. Acamprosate calms that chaos.
It’s taken three times a day, and you can start it while still drinking, though it’s most effective after detox. Side effects are usually mild: diarrhea, nausea, or dizziness. Unlike naltrexone, it doesn’t interact with opioids, so it’s safe for people with past opioid use who aren’t currently using. But it doesn’t help with opioid cravings at all.
Buprenorphine (Suboxone, Subutex)
Buprenorphine is the gold standard for opioid dependence. It’s a partial opioid agonist, meaning it activates opioid receptors just enough to reduce cravings and withdrawal - but not enough to cause a strong high. That’s why it’s safer than methadone. People on buprenorphine can function normally, hold jobs, and avoid the cycle of using and crashing.
It’s often combined with naloxone (Suboxone) to prevent misuse. If someone tries to inject it, naloxone blocks the effect. Buprenorphine can be prescribed by certified doctors in outpatient settings, which makes access easier than methadone clinics.
Unlike naltrexone, you don’t need to be fully detoxed before starting. In fact, many people begin buprenorphine while still experiencing mild withdrawal. That’s a big advantage for people who’ve struggled to stay off opioids long enough to start naltrexone.
Nalmefene
Nalmefene is similar to naltrexone - it’s also an opioid receptor antagonist. It’s approved in some countries for alcohol dependence, especially for people who don’t want to quit entirely but want to cut down. It’s taken on an as-needed basis: one hour before drinking. This makes it ideal for social drinkers who struggle with binge episodes.
It’s not FDA-approved in the U.S. for alcohol use, but it’s used off-label in some clinics. It has a longer half-life than naltrexone, so one dose lasts longer. Side effects are similar: nausea, dizziness, headache. But because it’s taken only when needed, some people find it easier to stick with than daily pills.
Methadone
Methadone is a full opioid agonist. It’s been used for decades to treat opioid addiction. It’s taken daily in supervised clinics, which can be a barrier for some. But it’s very effective at reducing cravings and preventing withdrawal. Unlike naltrexone, methadone keeps opioid receptors activated - so users don’t feel the need to use street drugs.
The downside? It’s addictive. You can become dependent on methadone itself. Tapering off takes months or even years. It also carries a risk of overdose if misused, especially when mixed with other depressants like alcohol or benzodiazepines.
For people who’ve tried naltrexone and failed - often because they couldn’t stay off opioids long enough to start it - methadone might be a better bridge. But it’s not a good fit for those who want to avoid any opioid-like medication.
Comparison Table: Naltrexone vs. Alternatives
| Medication | Primary Use | Form | Start Requirements | Dependence Risk | Key Advantage | Key Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Naltrexone Opioid receptor antagonist used for alcohol and opioid dependence | Alcohol, Opioids | Pill, Monthly Injection | 7-10 days opioid-free | None | No risk of dependence; blocks highs | Hard to start if still using opioids |
| Acamprosate Stabilizes brain chemistry after alcohol cessation | Alcohol only | Three times daily pill | Can start while drinking | None | Reduces post-acute cravings | Doesn’t help with opioids |
| Buprenorphine Partial opioid agonist for opioid dependence | Opioids only | Sublingual tablet or film | Can start with mild withdrawal | Mild to moderate | Reduces cravings without full high | Can be misused; requires ongoing prescription |
| Nalmefene Opioid antagonist used on-demand for alcohol reduction | Alcohol (as-needed) | Oral tablet | Take one hour before drinking | None | Flexible use for social drinkers | Not FDA-approved in U.S. for alcohol |
| Methadone Full opioid agonist for opioid dependence | Opioids only | Daily liquid or pill | Can start with withdrawal | High | Very effective for severe dependence | Requires daily clinic visits; risk of overdose |
Who Benefits Most From Each Option?
If you’ve tried to quit drinking and keep relapsing because you miss the feeling - and you’re willing to go through a full detox - naltrexone could be your best bet. It’s ideal for people who want to stop completely and avoid any medication that could be misused.
If you’re still drinking socially but want to cut back, nalmefene (if available) gives you control without needing to quit cold turkey. It’s like having a safety net before a party.
If your main problem is opioids and you’ve failed to stay clean long enough to start naltrexone, buprenorphine is likely your most realistic path. It doesn’t require a long detox. Many people stay on it for months or years - and that’s okay. Recovery isn’t about being drug-free overnight. It’s about staying alive and rebuilding your life.
Acamprosate is perfect for someone who’s been sober for a few weeks but still feels anxious, restless, and on edge. It doesn’t touch cravings from opioids, but it can be the missing piece for alcohol recovery.
Methadone works best for people with long-term, severe opioid dependence who’ve tried everything else. It’s not glamorous, but it saves lives.
Why Naltrexone Often Fails
Naltrexone has a high dropout rate - nearly half of people stop taking it within three months. Why? Because it doesn’t make you feel better. It doesn’t reduce anxiety or improve sleep. It doesn’t give you a high. It just blocks the high. If you’re not motivated, or if your environment still triggers cravings, you’ll probably stop.
It’s not a magic pill. It works best when paired with counseling, support groups, or lifestyle changes. People who take naltrexone and go to therapy regularly are far more likely to stay on it and stay sober.
Also, the monthly injection (Vivitrol) helps with adherence. If you forget pills, the shot takes care of it. But it’s expensive, and not all insurance covers it. The pill version is cheaper, but harder to stick with.
What to Do If Naltrexone Didn’t Work for You
It’s not a failure. It just means that medication isn’t the only tool you need - or maybe it’s not the right one. Talk to your doctor about switching. Try buprenorphine if opioids are the issue. Add acamprosate if you’re still drinking. Explore nalmefene if you’re in a country where it’s available.
Some people use naltrexone and buprenorphine together - but only under strict medical supervision. That’s not standard, but it’s been done in complex cases. Never combine medications without a doctor’s guidance.
Also, consider non-medication support: cognitive behavioral therapy, peer support groups like SMART Recovery or Alcoholics Anonymous, or even mindfulness training. Medication helps with the biology. Therapy helps with the psychology. You need both.
Final Thoughts
Naltrexone is a powerful tool - but it’s not the only one. The best treatment is the one you can stick with. If you can’t get past the detox requirement, buprenorphine might be more realistic. If you’re still drinking socially, nalmefene could be a game-changer. If your brain feels broken after quitting alcohol, acamprosate might be the quiet helper you didn’t know you needed.
There’s no single right answer. Recovery isn’t about picking the "best" drug. It’s about finding the right fit for your life, your history, and your goals. Don’t give up if one option didn’t work. Try another. Keep talking to your doctor. Your path to recovery is yours alone - and there are more options than you think.
Can I take naltrexone if I’m still using opioids?
No. Taking naltrexone while opioids are still in your system can trigger sudden, severe withdrawal symptoms, including nausea, vomiting, sweating, and anxiety. You must be completely opioid-free for 7-10 days before starting naltrexone. Your doctor will likely test you to confirm this.
Is naltrexone better than methadone for opioid addiction?
It depends. Naltrexone blocks opioids entirely and has no addiction risk, but you must be fully detoxed first - which many people can’t do. Methadone keeps opioid receptors activated to reduce cravings and withdrawal, making it easier to start and maintain treatment. Methadone works better for severe, long-term dependence, but carries a risk of dependence itself.
Does naltrexone help with alcohol cravings?
Yes, but indirectly. Naltrexone reduces the pleasurable effects of alcohol, which lowers the urge to drink over time. It doesn’t eliminate cravings like acamprosate does. For best results, combine it with counseling to address the emotional triggers behind drinking.
Can I drink alcohol while taking naltrexone?
You can, but you won’t feel the usual effects - no euphoria, no relaxation. Some people use this as motivation to stop drinking entirely. However, drinking while on naltrexone doesn’t cause dangerous reactions - it just feels flat. The goal is to break the link between alcohol and reward.
How long should I stay on naltrexone?
There’s no fixed timeline. Most experts recommend at least 6-12 months. For some, it’s a year. For others, it’s years. The goal isn’t to take it forever - it’s to build new habits and coping skills. Many people taper off after a year if they’ve stayed sober and developed strong support systems.
Is the naltrexone shot better than the pill?
The shot (Vivitrol) ensures you take it every month, so it’s better for people who forget pills. It also avoids daily dosing and potential misuse. But it’s more expensive and requires a doctor’s visit. The pill is cheaper and easier to start, but you must remember to take it daily. Both are equally effective if taken as prescribed.
Comments (10)
Jens Petersen
Let’s be real - naltrexone is the only option for people who actually want to recover instead of just swapping one dependency for another. Methadone? That’s just opioid maintenance with a side of clinic bureaucracy. Buprenorphine’s not much better - you’re still chasing a partial high while pretending you’re "in recovery." Acamprosate? Cute. It’s like putting a bandaid on a severed artery. If you’re not willing to sit with the discomfort of sobriety, then yeah, you’ll fail naltrexone. But that’s not the drug’s fault - it’s yours.
And don’t get me started on nalmefene. "Take one pill before drinking"? That’s not recovery, that’s a permission slip for bingeing. You’re not a social drinker - you’re a control addict who needs to believe you can still have it all. Spoiler: you can’t.
The injection? Brilliant. No more daily willpower tests. No more "I’ll take it tomorrow." It’s a commitment device disguised as a shot. If you can’t commit to monthly shots, you’re not ready for sobriety. Period.
And yes, therapy is non-negotiable. If you think medication alone fixes broken brains, you’re living in a pharmaceutical fantasyland. This isn’t a vitamin - it’s a psychological overhaul. You need to rewire your reward system, not just block it.
Also, the fact that people still think "methadone saves lives" is why addiction treatment is stuck in the 1970s. It keeps you alive, sure. But it doesn’t give you a life. Naltrexone forces you to build one. That’s the difference between survival and recovery.
Stop romanticizing dependence. Stop calling buprenorphine "gentler." It’s still an opioid. You’re not healing - you’re substituting. And if you’re proud of that, you’re not in recovery. You’re in denial with better insurance.
Keerthi Kumar
Thank you for this deeply thoughtful breakdown - I come from India, where addiction is still shrouded in shame, and access to even basic treatment is a luxury. In many villages, people believe addiction is a moral failing - not a brain disorder. This article, in its clarity, becomes a quiet revolution.
I’ve seen friends try naltrexone, and yes - the 7–10 day detox is brutal. But what’s more brutal? Watching someone die slowly from withdrawal or relapse. I’ve seen families choose methadone because it’s "easier," but then the person becomes a shadow - alive, yes, but never present. Acamprosate? I wish it were available here. The emotional turbulence after quitting alcohol - the insomnia, the dread - it’s like walking through glass.
And nalmefene? In India, we don’t have it, but I’ve heard of people using it in Europe. The idea of "on-demand" use feels radical here. We don’t have the language for harm reduction - only abstinence or failure. But perhaps, in time, we’ll learn that recovery isn’t binary. It’s a spectrum - and sometimes, one pill before a wedding is better than a funeral.
Let’s stop judging. Let’s start equipping. We need more clinics, more education, more compassion. Not just in the U.S. - everywhere.
Dade Hughston
So like naltrexone is supposed to be this magic bullet right but like most people just cant even get through the detox like i tried it twice and both times i was like okay im gonna do it but then like 3 days in i started sweating and shaking and my brain was like NOPE and i just drank again and it was like oh wait i can still feel the buzz and i was like why am i doing this again
and the shot is like 1000 bucks and my insurance said no so i just got the pill and then i forgot it for like two weeks and then i was like oh right i take this thing and then i was like why am i even taking it if i dont even feel anything
and then i saw this guy on tiktok say buprenorphine is the real MVP and now i’m on it and honestly like i dont feel high but i dont feel like i want to die either and my job didnt fire me and my dog still likes me so like maybe this is the one
also i think the whole "you have to be clean for 10 days" thing is just a trap designed by pharma to make you give up before you even start
and why does everyone act like therapy is the answer like i dont need to talk about my childhood i need a pill that works and i dont need to be judged for still wanting to drink sometimes
Jim Peddle
Let’s not pretend this isn’t a controlled experiment in population management. Naltrexone is marketed as "non-addictive" - but who benefits? The pharmaceutical companies who own Vivitrol. The clinics that charge $500 per injection. The insurance companies that refuse to cover buprenorphine because it’s cheaper than naltrexone’s monthly shot.
Why is nalmefene banned in the U.S.? Because it doesn’t lock people into lifelong dependency. It’s a harm-reduction tool - and harm reduction is seen as enabling by the very institutions that profit from addiction-as-a-chronic-disease model.
Methadone clinics? They’re state-sanctioned opium dens with waiting rooms. You’re not healing - you’re being managed. And buprenorphine? It’s just a slower drip of the same poison. Only naltrexone offers true freedom - but only if you survive the detox. And guess who gets left behind? The poor. The homeless. The mentally ill. The ones who can’t afford to be opioid-free for ten days.
This isn’t medicine. It’s social sorting. And the language of "recovery"? Just PR.
S Love
First - thank you for writing this with such care. It’s rare to see a post that doesn’t reduce addiction to a simple choice between good and bad drugs.
I’ve been on naltrexone for 14 months. I started because I was drinking three bottles of wine a week and lying to my kids about where I was going. The first month was hell - I felt nothing. Not sad. Not happy. Just flat. But I kept going. I went to AA. I started journaling. I got a dog.
After six months, I stopped craving alcohol. Not because naltrexone made me not want it - but because I’d built a life where I didn’t need it anymore.
To anyone reading this who thinks this won’t work for them: it’s not about the drug. It’s about the structure around it. The therapy. The community. The sleep. The therapy. The routine. The therapy.
Naltrexone is a tool. Not a cure. But if you’re willing to use it with intention - it can be the anchor you didn’t know you needed.
You’re not broken. You’re rebuilding. And that’s brave.
Pritesh Mehta
Western medicine has turned addiction into a corporate product line - naltrexone, buprenorphine, methadone - all patented, all expensive, all designed to keep you paying for decades. In India, we have yoga, meditation, community, and spiritual discipline - none of which require a prescription or insurance card. We don’t need to inject chemicals into our bodies to find peace. We need to reconnect with ourselves - not with pharmaceutical CEOs.
Why do you think so many Americans relapse? Because they’ve outsourced their healing to pills. They think a shot or a tablet will fix their trauma. But trauma doesn’t live in the opioid receptors - it lives in the soul.
Let me be clear: I’m not saying medication has no place. But when the entire system is built on dependency - chemical, financial, institutional - then the so-called "recovery" industry is just another form of colonial control.
True healing comes from silence. From breath. From belonging. Not from a monthly injection.
Billy Tiger
They want you to believe naltrexone is the answer but they don’t tell you the truth - it’s just another way to keep you docile while they profit. Methadone clinics are government-run opium dens. Buprenorphine is a slow drip of the same poison. And Vivitrol? That’s corporate greed in a syringe. They don’t care if you recover. They care if you keep paying.
And the whole "you need therapy" thing? That’s just to make you feel guilty for not being perfect. Like if you don’t journal and meditate and go to 90 meetings in 90 days you’re a failure. Newsflash - I’m not trying to be a saint. I just want to stop dying.
Why is nalmefene banned? Because it’s too simple. Too cheap. Too honest. Let people take a pill before they drink and they might not need a whole damn system.
They want you dependent on their system. Not free.
Emmalee Amthor
I was on naltrexone for 8 months and I quit because I felt like a ghost - like I was watching my life through fogged glass. But then I switched to buprenorphine and for the first time in years I slept through the night. I cried. I laughed. I called my mom. I didn’t want to die anymore. And yeah I’m still on it. So what? I’m alive. And I’m not ashamed. Recovery isn’t about being clean - it’s about being here. And I’m here.
Leslie Schnack
Can someone explain why nalmefene isn’t FDA-approved for alcohol use in the U.S.? The mechanism makes sense - on-demand use for social drinkers. It’s like having a seatbelt for binge episodes. Why is this being blocked? Is it because it doesn’t fit the addiction-as-chronic-disease model? Or is it just profit-driven? I’ve read studies from Sweden and Finland - it works. So why not here?
Saumyata Tiwari
Western medicine has failed. You treat addiction like a broken machine - fix the receptors, fix the brain, fix the person. But in India, we know addiction is a cry for connection. You don’t cure it with pills. You cure it with community. With a mother’s embrace. With a village that refuses to let you fall. Naltrexone? It’s a Band-Aid on a gaping wound. And you wonder why people relapse? Because they’re alone. Not because they lack willpower.
Stop medicalizing suffering. Start humanizing it.